On Tisha B’av, the meaning of Tree of Life revealed

by Msnbctv news staff


(RNS) — The positioning of essentially the most lethal assault on Jews in U.S. historical past is on the point of rebuild.

In early Might, the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh introduced that Daniel Libeskind, the architect of Berlin’s Jewish Museum and the grasp planner of the World Commerce Heart district after 9/11, had been commissioned to revamp Tree of Life as a worship area that may share area with the Holocaust Heart of Pittsburgh in addition to a Corridor of Recollections concerning the assault.

After his first go to to the location, Libeskind instructed the Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle that his objective is to “affirm life, but in addition tackle what occurred, why we’re constructing a brand new constructing within the first place.” He added, “It is a place the place Jews have been murdered as a result of they have been Jews, as a result of they have been praying in a synagogue,” and continued: “This isn’t simply native. It is a mission that ought to contact everybody’s coronary heart.”

Libeskind said that he hopes to attain these targets “by way of mild, acoustics and the supplies used.”


RELATED: Tree of Life names famend architect Daniel Libeskind to design synagogue advanced


As a member of New Mild, one of many congregations that rented area at Tree of Life on the time of the capturing although we don’t count on to return, I’ve been considering deeply about what messages I’d like these visiting the area to come back away with. I’ve a couple of concepts for Libeskind — not design concepts; that’s not my area. However right here are some things Libeskind would possibly consider as he goes about his work.

Architect Daniel Libeskind in Rome on Oct. 21, 2016. (AP Photograph/Andrew Medichini)

A number of months after the capturing, in an try and make sense of what had occurred and start to assume to the longer term, I sat down with Eric Lidji, director of the Rauh Jewish Historical past Program & Archives on the Senator John Heinz Historical past Heart in Pittsburgh, and historian of reminiscence James Younger, who directs the Institute for Holocaust, Genocide and Reminiscence Research on the College of Massachusetts Amherst.

Earlier than a memorial may be created, Younger mentioned, the which means of the occasion has to coalesce. Was the capturing about antisemitism, gun violence, the significance of examine and worship on the Jewish Sabbath, or the place of Jews in America? Is that this an upending of the anticipated, that we’re secure right here, or is it a continuation of centuries of Jew hatred that we’ve got confronted in each neighborhood wherein we reside?

Ought to we recall the aftermath of the violence — an outpouring of assist from each the non- Jewish neighborhood right here in Pittsburgh, with clergy of each doable denomination who got here to a public memorial service the day after the capturing, and from Jews around the globe? 

This previous week Jews noticed Tisha B’Av, the day on which Jews commemorate the destruction of each historical temples in Jerusalem and the numerous different calamities to have befallen us. It’s the heaviest of days, once we ponder the load of historical past and the inconceivable survival of our folks. Within the nineteenth kinah of the liturgical poems of lamentation we recite on Tisha B’av, we are saying “anu kiyamim” — “We now have survived.” 

The rabbi on the synagogue I used to be attending advised that as a part of our commentary of the vacation, we go ourselves to the Tree of Life web site.

Uncertain, I later walked alone the few quick blocks alongside Shady Avenue. It was odd to face there at a spot so targeted on neighborhood with nobody beside me. One educating I realized this week is that after the burning of the temple commenced, God determined that the constructing can be destroyed however the Jewish folks can be saved. At Tree of Life, I believed, it was the individuals who have been killed and scattered and the constructing that was saved.

One of many major objectives of Tisha B’av, as Yael Ziegler explains in her current commentary on the Ebook of Lamentations, is to remind us to behave as a collective, to see ourselves as a united neighborhood. That motion from the person to the communal needs to be an integral thought in a brand new Tree of Life. From Shady Avenue, I walked across the nook to take a look at the objects collected in a gallery contained in the constructing seen from the surface. So many messages and objects, from the 11 glass flowers — one for every capturing sufferer — blooming continuously to the crocheted Jewish stars with hearts in them positioned there and elsewhere across the neighborhood, to the white picket Jewish stars positioned by Greg Zanis, who earlier than his demise final 12 months would go to websites of mass violence to honor the victims.

Monique Mead plays her violin on the sidewalk outside the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh on Sunday, Oct. 27, 2019, the first anniversary of the shooting at the synagogue that killed 11 worshippers. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)

Monique Mead performs her violin on the sidewalk outdoors the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh on Oct. 27, 2019, the primary anniversary of the capturing on the synagogue that killed 11 worshippers. (AP Photograph/Gene J. Puskar)

The Ebook of Exodus tells us that in constructing the tabernacle within the desert, all of the folks gave ultimately, directed by Bezalel, the craftsperson and visionary who tailored the plans at Moses’ route.

That is what I need for the brand new Tree of Life, and that is the which means of what occurred: a testomony to the survival of a neighborhood; the willpower and love for Judaism of all three of the synagogues that worshipped within the area, and people persevering with to worship there; the sense of defiance that every one of Squirrel Hill, not simply Jews, confirmed to deflect the shooter’s hate. 


RELATED: The Jewish reply to how you can punish the Pittsburgh synagogue shooter


Throughout the road from Tree of Life is the Kids’s Institute of Pittsburgh. Its motto? “To Heal. To Educate. To Empower. To Amaze.”

That looks as if a reasonably good information for Daniel Libeskind. The brand new Tree of Life ought to heal these locally and people who go to. It ought to educate them what Judaism is and why Jews are keen to be martyrs for it. The construction ought to empower guests to struggle hatred of all types, not simply towards Jews however all sorts of intolerance. Lastly, amaze with what may be finished by a grasp architect like your self. 

A tall order, however then that’s the reason you have been employed. I sit up for seeing your design and the ultimate work, hoping that it helps our neighborhood to proceed to deal with the trauma we’ve got skilled, to heal and to honor the reminiscences of those that have been slain. 

(Beth Kissileff, a journalist in Pittsburgh, is co-editor of the 2020 guide “Sure within the Bond of Life: Pittsburgh Writers Mirror on the Tree of Life Tragedy” and editor of the forthcoming “Studying Exodus: Journeys.” The views expressed on this commentary don’t essentially replicate these of Faith Information Service.)



Source link

You may also like